Have you ever wondered how it would feel to walk through the halls of Niles West, facing your teachers, peers, and friends while openly supporting Donald Trump? Well, that’s exactly what I did.
Before I tell you the horrors of my day, I want to make clear: No, I don’t actually support Donald Trump.
I looked at this experiment in a very unbiased way because I do not support a stuck-up, racist bigot like Donald Trump or a lying, corrupt politician like Hillary Clinton. I stand as a moderate; I like some ideas from both the Republican Party and the Democratic Party, but let’s be honest, this year’s nominees aren’t that stellar.
What really made this experiment even more interesting for me than it already was is the irony of it, seeing as I am a Muslim appearing to support the same man who swears to ban the entrance of Muslims into the United States.
Naturally, I assumed some people might not take me seriously, knowing my religious identity and considering Trump’s hate of Muslims. I at least expected people to arrive at the question, “Why would a Muslim support Trump?”
Keeping that in mind, I showed up to Niles West last Tuesday wearing a Trump t-shirt bearing his infamous slogan ‘Make America Great Again.’ My goal was to see people’s reactions. Would people who saw me with this shirt look at me in a different or negative way?
Throughout the day, not only was I given dirty looks by most people I passed in the hallway, but I was stared at by nearly everyone in my classes. I felt the eyes follow me and heard people snickering at me.
I decided to go into the library and ask people for their opinions on what kind of person they would assume I was, based solely on my attire.
Some people were quick to assume I was probably a jerk because of my shirt.
“I think you’re more racist, more stupid in a way for wearing a shirt like that,” senior Alissa Santana said.
One girl, who wished to remain anonymous, had even more to say about me.
“I automatically thought you were a horrible person, and I would never, ever, ever talk to you,” she said.
As you could probably tell, my day was going great so far.
Although I was being judged by most students, what really caught my attention was how my teachers reacted.
“I didn’t think you would wear something like that,” one of my teachers commented.
And that’s what bothered me the most. How do my political views, even if they are as outrageous as supporting Trump, automatically categorize me as a completely different person, or make people assume I’m probably not that smart anymore?
I’m still the same person at the end of the day, and I don’t think someone’s political views should be used to determine what kind of person they are or how intelligent they might be.
Around the middle of the day, I did pass by a guy who on first sight of me, began to scream “So you want to build a wall?” repeatedly at me, while walking away in disbelief.
And I did hear a couple of ‘Oh, wows’ here and there.
But eighth period is when things mostly began to heat up. Just to give a little background, I generally get along with my eighth period class really well — most people in there are really nice once you get to know them, and I typically get along with everyone in class, talking to them at a friendly level day to day.
I remember that at the start of class, after talking to my teacher, I went back to my seat. A friend of mine began laughing and talking to me like we usually do, but within a minute, when she caught sign of my shirt, she stopped talking and smiling, looked at me in the eye and said, “I can’t talk to you anymore.”
Soon after, two other girls who sat in front of me took a closer look at what I was wearing. Their jaws dropped, and one of them commented, “We thought you were smarter.”
Going back to what I mentioned before, how do my political views make people think they can assume I’m unintelligent or a bad person? I’m still the same old me.
To wrap up my already interesting day, on the way to a club after school, two girls snickered at me, with one of of them saying, “You’re a disgrace to Niles West,” and the other, “You should burn that shirt.”
That pretty much sums up my day.
However, not everyone immediately disagreed with me.
On my way to class, one guy saw me and gave me a peace sign, and someone else gave me a heads up in approval.
Others, at the very least, respected my supposed support for Trump.
“I don’t agree with your choice, but I still respect it,” sophomore Alyssa Concepcion admitted.
But the ratio of teens and adults who disagreed and judged me was much much higher than individuals who agreed or respected my choice.
In summary:
I learned two things from my experiment.
- Niles West really hates Trump. And I mean really.
- Most people at our school are undecided or moderates (not liberal or conservative)
Some agree they don’t stand with either candidate.
“Personally, I think they both are bad candidates,” Santana said.
But most said they would prefer Hillary over Trump.
“Hillary is not as dumb as Trump, to be honest,” Santana added.
Although I dislike Donald Trump as much as the next person here at West, I still think it’s important not to be quick to assume someone’s characteristics just because they support him.
It really is sad that some people can’t express their political opinions in school without getting snickers or being judged. What I went through might not have offended me, but it could possibly be to someone else if they really were a Trump supporter.
Just think, how often do you see someone wearing a Trump shirt or cap compared to wearing a Clinton shirt, or Tammy Duckworth shirt, or any other politician?
Chances are you’ll be more likely to see someone wearing any other politicians shirt besides Trump’s, and that could be because they know they will be judged and treated badly just for who they support.
English Teacher Michele Lewis agrees that people shouldn’t be judged for their political views.
“I think it just represents the serious schism in our society that needs to be amended. People should not be so incensed by others political views,” Lewis said.
But the reactions I received don’t just represent what Niles West thinks; it’s how much of our country also feels.
“It’s a sad statement so many people in our country feel this way,” Lewis adds.
And I couldn’t agree more. I mean, imagine going to your local park or any grocery store in the Chicago area. Would you feel more secure wearing a Clinton shirt or Trump shirt? I’ll let you decide.
In short, even if you vote for someone as racist or obnoxious as Donald J. Trump, it shouldn’t make others change how they view you, no matter how liberal or conservative you might be.
Larry • Mar 19, 2017 at 6:33 PM
Probably the most daring or actually outgoing experiment the Niles West News has actually done this year. Not that I don’t like the other articles- I just think you guys should conduct more social experiments
Hanna R. • Jan 28, 2017 at 8:59 PM
This doesn’t take into account people like myself who wouldn’t judge someone the same way for supporting Cruz or Carson as I would Trump. He’s said things that have made people think of Hitler. That’s a serious comparison, and it’s scary. The things he’s done so far are worrying as well. As for people judging you, the trend with most Trump supporters is that they are uneducated, blue collar workers. These people aren’t exactly the brightest of the bunch. I’ve tried to talk with Trump supporters about the concerns people have with him, but their responses are usually not thought out, hard to understand, or just insulting (although I don’t find myself insulted by them). I withhold judgement on people being racist, homophobic, or misogynistic themselves, but to support someone who is makes me concerned as to what kind of person they are that they can ignore that about their candidate.
Ice T • Nov 11, 2016 at 12:54 PM
It’s funny because everyone was giving hate to Zubare, but like on wednesday I saw a kid wearing a shirt promoting trump and no one was giving him hate.
Sharon Swanson • Oct 20, 2016 at 10:58 AM
This was an excellent article–you wrote the facts–what happened to you. People need to a) read the entire article, and b) think before they respond.
Zubair Muhammad • Oct 20, 2016 at 8:27 AM
For everyone slamming me for being bias, I would like to mention that I don’t like Hillary either. If you take the time to read through the whole article, I did mention that I don’t support a ‘corrupt lying politician’ like Hillary either so it’s not like I’m only blasting Trump; I don’t stand with either candidate. The purpose of this experiment was to see just how critical people are to others for their political views or even something as minor as wearing a T-Shirt, not just to blast Trump. And for whoever said most West students support Trump, take a minute to open your eyes and realize what a mostly liberal and diverse school we are. I hope everyone can respect other’s opinions before commenting furthermore. Thank you and have a great day!
thomas j • Oct 19, 2016 at 9:17 PM
what a joke of an article. you are so biased against trump even though you say you are unbiased. just cuz he doesn’t want muslims immigrating doesn’t make him a racist
Hey • Oct 19, 2016 at 6:35 PM
This was a disgrace. I honestly though you are a better person. I am personally voting for Jill stein but the way you kept showing your hatred with trump infuriated me. In the beginning of our article you stated it was unbiased. That boiled my blood because the whole article was bias. Try finding something else to do besides writing.
NotADemocRAT • Oct 19, 2016 at 3:06 PM
Just goes to show how idiotic and messed up the Niles West Administration is. Niles West students are naive and just plain stupid. Hillary Lied, Men Died. Trump said a few nasty words, grow a pair Niles West!
Vraj • Oct 18, 2016 at 7:56 PM
First of all, Zubair, you are awesome. However, I completely disagree with you. You need to realize that this election is not like a traditional one. When you CHOOSE TO EXPRESS your political beliefs, you are also agreeing to the candidate’s policies and views. Of course, you SHOULD NOT be judged by your political views. However, is Trump really just a politician? He is racist, CRIMINAL, or ignorant at best. When you say you support him, you are agreeing that what he did to womEn was acceptable. No wonder why every girl will hate you for showing any bit of support for Trump. Being conservative, liberal, moderate or anything is a political ideology; if anyone disrespects you, then feel free to talk to your dean. However, Trump is not just the politician; Trump is a collection of filthy acts. It is a similar situation: why is supporting Hitler bad? There are just some things that are just wrong.
Ivana Kosir • Oct 18, 2016 at 7:28 PM
Zubair, great article! As former editor-in-chief, I wrote a column regarding political intolerance in the 2012 election. It’s unfortunate that not much has changed, even with political tensions in America being at a seemingly all-time high. Keep up the great reporting, though!
Michael • Feb 2, 2017 at 10:33 PM
He is your president now!
Zeeshan Khan • Oct 18, 2016 at 7:13 PM
This article is not only super biased (“…someone as racist or obnoxious as Donald J. Trump”), it’s straight up wrong. Way more West students support Trump than this kid makes it seem like and his friends likely aren’t representative of Niles West. I also like how he conveniently doesn’t support any candidate as if that validates what he says. Why not just talk to West students who actually support Trump?
:-] • Oct 17, 2016 at 10:14 PM
I really like this article, and I commend you for breaking social norms. It is ironic how so many people at Niles West “try” not to be judgmental. I mean… Wasn’t there a “Don’t Judge Me Challenge” going viral not so long ago? The irony is just so hilarious. I guess doing this experiment differentiates who you should and should not associate yourself with. Those that AT LEAST attempt to separate their partisanship from friendship are the ones you should stay with; those that discover something about and completely change their demeanor around you are the ones you should withdraw from.
:) • Oct 19, 2016 at 8:04 PM
Thank you for explaining to people how it feels to be a Trump Supporter. I just want to clarify that I am not a white supremacist. I am an Asian-American that loves learning about other cultures and languages. I agree that it is very difficult to be a Trump supporter. I don’t tell anybody that I support Trump unless I feel like I can really trust them and that they wouldn’t judge me. I don’t hate democrats for supporting Hilary. I respect their opinion as long as they aren’t just following what everyone else thinks and think for themselves who is the best for our country based on all of the information out there. It is a shame that I feel that I will literally get beaten up if I wear any merchandise that shows that I support Trump. The media played a big role into portraying Trump as a racist when he isn’t. They play a snippet of what he said and don’t play the rest of it or the next speeches that have him clarify that he didn’t mean all Mexicans bring crime. I feel like he just has such a limited vocabulary and can’t express himself effectively and without a teleprompter, it just came out wrong. There are Hispanics out there that can see what he actually is trying to say. He isn’t against Muslims or Mexicans, but instead, he’s for temporarily taking precautions to make sure that we don’t make our country susceptible to ISIS and to try and get drugs out of our country like heroin. Look at what happened in Europe, especially France. Like preventative medicine, you try to stop the problem from even happening or as much as you actually can as possible. By doing this, he protects all Americans, whether they are Muslim, Christian, Jewish, atheist, agnostic, etc. As for immigration, he just wants people to follow the law and for others to have respect for our laws. Why do they think that they can just walk across the border without complying with our laws when many other people work hard and pay A LOT in fees to come here the legal way. He isn’t talking about Mexicans only, but every person coming in illegally. Even Mexico has a wall at its southern border and I’ve heard Rome does too. Why is it so bad to define our borders and make people follow the laws that make up our beautiful country? Trump welcomes immigrants as long as they come in the legal way, like my parent was able to do, though it was a difficult journey. But I do agree that we do need immigration reform, which we can do after we first enforce the current laws and let people know that we respect our laws and take them seriously and hope that others do to. The bottom line of why I support Trump is because I am anti-establishment and think I’d rather take a chance with Trump than have our country go into more debt. I want to make sure that me, my family, and friends still have a future. Who cares about being politically correct when so much more is at stake?
Hanna R. • Jan 28, 2017 at 10:35 PM
So you want a president that can’t even express themselves? Despite your opinion of him, you can’t deny Obama was a great public speaker. That was part of what made him presidential. If a person can’t convey things effectively, what happens when they piss off a person like the leader of North Korea? Nuclear warfare is a possibility now. It’s not a time for a leader who rubs people the wrong way.
laquin • Mar 22, 2017 at 7:20 PM
Yeah he was good at reading a teleprompter. Anyone with half a brain stem could do that. He was such a fake person, and overall a joke of a president.